How strong must the motor be at least, so the wheel has reserves for emergency braking and wobble?
Counter-argument: a powerful wheel can be speed-limited with tilt-back. Answer: the reserve matters at the permitted speed, not only at top speed.
Sources: Danish Road Traffic Authority (trial schemes), borgerforslag.dk, forum.electricunicycle.org (cutouts, wobble), Cosmo Connected and Lumos (helmet lights), the speed pedelec and 45 km/h moped rules.
Speed on the road
30 km/h
- +For: Close to cycling speed, so the speed difference is small
- +For: Shorter braking distance and less injury in a fall. 30 km/h matches a small moped (knallert 30)
- −Against: Well below the 50 km/h town traffic, so cars overtake closely
- −Against: Too slow for commuting on the road
- −Against: Hard to justify a plate and certificate at such a low speed
Speed on the road
35 km/h
- +For: Close to cycling speed, so the speed difference is small
- +For: Shorter braking distance and less injury in a fall. 30 km/h matches a small moped (knallert 30)
- −Against: Well below the 50 km/h town traffic, so cars overtake closely
- −Against: Too slow for commuting on the road
- −Against: Hard to justify a plate and certificate at such a low speed
Speed on the road
40 km/h
- +For: Close to cycling speed, so the speed difference is small
- +For: Shorter braking distance and less injury in a fall. 30 km/h matches a small moped (knallert 30)
- −Against: Well below the 50 km/h town traffic, so cars overtake closely
- −Against: Too slow for commuting on the road
- −Against: Hard to justify a plate and certificate at such a low speed
Speed on the road
45 km/h
- +For: The same as a 45 km/h moped and a speed pedelec, so the rules already exist
- +For: Easiest to win political support
- −Against: Slower than town traffic on many roads (50 km/h), so cars overtake closely
Speed on the road
50 km/h
- +For: Follows the town speed limit, so the EUC moves with traffic instead of being overtaken
- −Against: No existing Danish vehicle class with exactly this limit
- −Against: Needs a new rule. 55 km/h adds only a small margin above the town limit
Speed on the road
55 km/h
- +For: Follows the town speed limit, so the EUC moves with traffic instead of being overtaken
- −Against: No existing Danish vehicle class with exactly this limit
- −Against: Needs a new rule. 55 km/h adds only a small margin above the town limit
Speed on the road
60 km/h
- +For: Can keep up with traffic on many country roads outside town
- −Against: Higher speed means worse injuries in a fall
- −Against: Less politically realistic at first
Speed on the road
65 km/h
- +For: Can keep up with traffic on many country roads outside town
- −Against: Higher speed means worse injuries in a fall
- −Against: Less politically realistic at first
Speed on the road
70 km/h
- +For: Can keep up with traffic on most country roads (80 km/h is the general limit outside built-up areas)
- −Against: Close to motorcycle speed
- −Against: Probably needs motorcycle-like training and gear
- −Against: Very hard to get passed
Speed on the road
75 km/h
- +For: Can keep up with traffic on most country roads (80 km/h is the general limit outside built-up areas)
- −Against: Close to motorcycle speed
- −Against: Probably needs motorcycle-like training and gear
- −Against: Very hard to get passed
Speed on the road
80 km/h
- +For: Can keep up with traffic on most country roads (80 km/h is the general limit outside built-up areas)
- −Against: Close to motorcycle speed
- −Against: Probably needs motorcycle-like training and gear
- −Against: Very hard to get passed
Road or cycle path
Road only
- +For: Like a 45 km/h moped
- +For: No fast vehicles among cyclists
- −Against: Riders are placed among cars in city traffic
Road or cycle path
Cycle path required
- +For: Like speed pedelecs, so there is a precedent
- +For: Away from cars
- −Against: Busy cycle paths in cities
- −Against: Speed difference to ordinary cyclists
Road or cycle path
Hybrid
- +For: The rider picks the safest option for the situation
- −Against: Hard to enforce a lower speed on the cycle path
- −Against: More complex rules
Speed on cycle paths (if hybrid)
20 km/h
- +For: Same as today
- +For: Matches ordinary cyclists
- −Against: Too slow for commuting
- −Against: Many will choose the road
Speed on cycle paths (if hybrid)
25 km/h
- +For: Like ordinary e-bikes (pedelecs)
- +For: Flows with cycle traffic
- −Against: A little faster than many cyclists
Speed on cycle paths (if hybrid)
30 km/h
- +For: Realistic commuting speed
- −Against: Bigger speed difference
- −Against: May meet resistance from cyclists
Plate and rider number
No plate or number
- +For: Cheapest and simplest
- +For: As today
- −Against: Police cannot identify the wheel or the rider
- −Against: Hard to defend a higher speed without it
Plate and rider number
Registration sticker only
- +For: Small and easy to fit
- +For: Shows the wheel is registered
- −Against: Cannot be read from a distance or by speed cameras
Plate and rider number
Plate on the wheel only
- +For: Like a moped
- +For: Familiar to the police
- −Against: Needs a bracket (seat)
- −Against: The plate can be hard to see when the wheel leans
Plate and rider number
Rider number only
- +For: At eye level and easy to see
- +For: Follows the responsible person
- −Against: Not tied to a specific wheel
- −Against: A new system the police do not know
Plate and rider number
Plate + rider number
- +For: Both wheel and rider can be identified
- +For: The strongest argument towards the police
- −Against: Most hassle and most expensive
Rider requirement
No requirement
- +For: No barriers
- −Against: Almost impossible to get a higher speed passed without documented training
Rider requirement
EUC certificate only
- +For: Targeted at EUC riding
- +For: Open to people without a driving licence
- −Against: The certificate must first be created, with course providers and a test
Rider requirement
Driving licence only
- +For: Already exists
- +For: Easy for the police to check
- −Against: Teaches nothing about EUC riding
- −Against: Excludes many cyclists
Rider requirement
Driving licence + EUC certificate
- +For: Gives politicians the most confidence
- −Against: Expensive and excludes people without a driving licence
Rider requirement
Tiered
- +For: Easy access to cycle paths, higher requirements for road speed
- −Against: More complex to explain and enforce
Minimum motor power
2,000 W
- +For: Ensures reserve power against cutouts and for emergency braking
- −Against: Excludes smaller, lighter wheels
- −Against: Manufacturers state power differently
Minimum motor power
3,000 W
- +For: Ensures reserve power against cutouts and for emergency braking
- −Against: Excludes smaller, lighter wheels
- −Against: Manufacturers state power differently
Minimum motor power
4,000 W
- +For: Ensures reserve power against cutouts and for emergency braking
- −Against: Excludes smaller, lighter wheels
- −Against: Manufacturers state power differently
Minimum motor power
Depends on the rider's weight
- +For: More precise
- −Against: Hard to check
Gear in road mode
Full road gear
- +For: Protects against the typical injuries in a fall (head, face, wrists, knees, back)
- −Against: Price
- −Against: Hot in summer
Gear in road mode
Lighter gear
- +For: Cheaper and more comfortable
- −Against: Face, wrists and back unprotected at high speed
Gear in road mode
Helmet only
- +For: As today
- −Against: Hard to defend at higher speeds
Seat required: where?
Never required
- +For: Cheaper
- +For: No change to the wheel
- −Against: No natural place for a plate
- −Against: Fatigue on long rides
Seat required: where?
Road only
- +For: Stable seated riding at high speed
- +For: Room for the plate
- +For: Free choice on paths and in the woods
- −Against: Must be fitted and removed, or stay on all the time
Seat required: where?
Road and cycle path
- +For: One rule in town
- −Against: Unnecessary at low speed
Seat required: where?
Always required
- +For: Simple rule
- −Against: Limits technical riding off-road
Lights on the helmet
Not required
- +For: Cheap
- −Against: The wheel's lights sit low and are hard to see from a car
Lights on the helmet
Red rear light
- +For: Cheap
- +For: Seen at eye level
- −Against: Does not show braking or direction
Lights on the helmet
Rear light + brake light
- +For: Drivers see you braking
- +For: Already exists (e.g. Cosmo Connected, Lumos)
- −Against: Extra cost and charging
Lights on the helmet
Rear light + brake light + indicators
- +For: Shows direction, since EUC riders cannot always signal with an arm
- −Against: Needs a remote
- −Against: More gear
Lights on the helmet
Full set
- +For: Maximum visibility
- −Against: Most expensive and heaviest
Results and comments are shown once you have submitted your ballot.
That way other people's answers do not influence yours. Once you submit, all results and comments open at once.
0 have voted